PREAMBLE
Council met in Chambers Tuesday, 3 September 2024, to decide whether to affirm (keep) or rescind (withdraw) its 2023 decision to establish a General Maori Ward for our 2025 local government election – a 2023 decision made with no prior public consultation and incorrectly communicated as a unanimous decision (by all Councillors).

THE DEBATE ON THE DAY
Paraphrasing Fred Dagg’s “We Don’t Know How Lucky We Are”, the meeting was a good day for local democracy. In the Council Chamber (temporarily relocated to the Civic Centre in Mary Street to increase capacity), we had a good turnout (a little over 100), passion, good oratory, and respectful listening.

Public opinion was invited and given. Everyone was heard. Councillors presented their views, which are now on public record.

Remit: To affirm the decision to establish a Māori Ward
In Favour: Len Salt (Mayor), Crs. Giri-Percival, Connell, Gotlieb, Sinclair, Rodley, Morrissey, and Revell Cr Revell was absent 3/9/24. He voted in favour of the decision to establish a Maori Ward in October 2023..
Against: Cr Grant. Abstaining: Cr Walker (Deputy Mayor)
With Councillors voting to affirm their decision for the 2025 election, s 39 of the Local Government (Electoral Legislation and Māori Wards and Māori Constituencies) Amendment Act 2024 Act states we must have a 2025 binding poll about a General Maori Ward for the 2028 local government elections and beyond. This binding poll allows the electorate to decide;

A PERVERSE OUTCOME
Because of the decision on 3 September, we potentially face the perverse situation whereby a General Maori Ward Councillor is to be elected in 2025 (for 2025-28) whilst the electorate contemporaneously decides it does not want a General Māori Ward for the 2028 election onwards. A Maori Councillor would, therefore, become a one-term Councillor, having been elected without a mandate from the people but a mandate from eight Councillors who unilaterally decided to establish a General Māori Ward.
THE DEBATE TO COME
The decision to have, or not to have, one or more Māori Wards is structurally a critical decision for our local democracy. Genuine, transparent consultation underpinned by a rigorous process should be non-negotiable. Without it, any outcome or decision will be challenging to justify. When followed and adhered to, the decision, whilst potentially unpopular amongst some, the integrity of the decision itself becomes beyond approach.
DECISION TIME
October 2025 is decision time with the local government election and binding poll. It is when we hold our Councillors to account. Before that happens, the Councillors supporting the remit and those who didn’t all need to ensure appropriate funding is available for an informed, robust public debate. We must get this decision right to avoid it becoming a recurring, central government political football. This is about us, our local community.
We cannot just be spectators. We must be the driving force behind our local democracy. We owe that to ourselves, our representatives, and our democracy.What do you think?
Please refer to the TCDC website for the replay of 3 September meeting.
From the Editor
