Alastair Brickell’s second energy article (Informer 3 Sept) is a glaring example of “Don’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good.” He dismisses renewable energy as not totally flawless while ignoring the far greater economic, health and environmental harm caused by coal burning.
Mr Brickell again overlooks that renewable energy costs just a third of coal generation. He seems unaware that coal plants waste two-thirds of their energy as heat, solar generation cuts emissions by 97-98% compared to coal, and coal extraction consumes 20-30 times more material than wind or solar.

Renewables are job rich. 142,000 clean energy jobs were added to the US economy in 2023, double that of overall jobs. Coal jobs fell nearly 8,500. (Reuters). Whitianga’s Lodestone solar farm is creating many local jobs.
Government and energy industry experts contradict Mr Brickell’s fearmongering about a non-existent energy crisis in New Zealand. His alarmist cries about our “broken” energy system
coincided with a one-day spike in wholesale electricity prices to $800MW/H. Prices have since plummeted to an average of $100 MW/H, thanks to – surprise, surprise – strong winds and rainfall.
Why didn’t Mr Brickell consult reputable sources like the New Zealand Electricity Authority? Maybe because they confirm that despite strong demand growth from electrifying our economy and transport, we can still meet our 2030 renewable energy targets.
The “intermittency problem” that Mr Brickell catastrophises to justify coal use? It’s a molehill he’s turned into a mountain. Experts confirm it can be solved with a suite of storage options including 1 TWh of grid-scale batteries. These batteries can meet 3-4 hours of peak demand during occasional cold winter nights, as explained by Victoria University Professor Alan Brent (The Conversation).
South Australia has already proven this model works, achieving 100% renewable energy including on cold winter nights, using solar power and large-scale batteries. Plus saving consumers money in the process! (energymining.sa.gov.au/).
New Zealand, with its massive hydroelectric reserves acting as a natural battery, needs fewer grid-scale batteries than other countries relying solely on solar or wind. Mr Brickell’s disingenuous dismissal of batteries and exaggeration of renewable intermittency ignores the rapid global growth of cheap renewable solutions.
If renewables are deeply flawed, as claimed by Mr Brickell why are they experiencing rapid worldwide expansion and adoption? Over the last decade, wind capacity increased by 250%, solar by 900%, and battery storage by a staggering 1,400%. Last year wind rose by 9%, solar by 22%, and grid-scale battery storage skyrocketed by 65-70%. And prices are still falling, meaning even faster uptake to come.
Meanwhile, global coal-fired electricity dropped by 2-3% last year. and no wealthy OECD nation has commissioned a coal plant since 2019. (International Energy Agency)
Another pesky detail Mr Brickell conveniently overlooks is the devastating health impact of coal. Heart attacks, strokes, lung diseases, and respiratory infections causing 1 million premature deaths annually and 10 to 15 million hospitalisations globally, are all dangerous impacts of coal-fired power. (World Health Organization). Solar and wind? Zero health impacts. But who needs healthy citizens when we can burn more coal, right?
Neither of Mr Brickell’s columns provides any credible sources, instead relying on unsubstantiated false equivalencies and “whataboutism” drawn from fossil fuel industry anti-renewable disinformation campaigns. Time therefore for some fact-checking:
Solar panels can withstand 2.5 cm hailstones with rare damage. Peanuts compared to climate change-driven flooding, and droughts severely impact water-dependent coal plants, e.g., $125 billion in losses from Hurricane Harvey, 2017 (EIA).
98% of solar panel materials are already being recycled in New Zealand (phoenixrecycling.co.nz/solar-panels). Recycling of wind turbines will follow as demand increases.
New perovskite solar cells have no silicon, so create no forced labour issues. Lodestone’s website confirms they ethically source their panels.
Germany hasn’t commissioned new coal plants as Mr Brickell suggests: – it shut down 15 in April 2024 while increasing renewables by 9.1%. (e3g.org/news/)
And the economic boon Mr Brickell touts from coal royalties? – a paltry $3 million in 2022 (nzpam.govt.nz). Truly a king’s ransom for our hospitals and schools!
Mr Brickell’s arguments are as outdated as the zombie technology he’s desperately trying to defend. There’s no energy crisis. Instead, we are on the cusp of unprecedented super-cheap renewable energy abundance. (rethinkx.com/energy)
