What does ‘the local voice being heard’ actually mean?

This Week's Issue

Written by

Pauline Stewart

Published on

Moewai Park Reserve Reclassification Debate. Councillors voted 5 to 4 to re-classify even though the Mercury Bay Community Board had brought a recommendation supported by 6 votes to 1 vote to NOT re-classify and that local submissions(10) had been unanimous that Moewai Park Reserve should not be re-classified.

Moewai Park Reserve. Photo taken in the last few days

This decision is not necessarily the end of the road. It is a decision that clearly demonstrates that the current Community Board’s voice has not been heeded. 

Location of Moewai Park Reserve.
Location of Moewai Park Reserve.

What seemed  like a simple strongly supported  recommendation from the Mercury Bay Community Board that would receive a lot of support from Councillors became a drawn out debate with the addition of a District manager’s presentation.  It ended in a 5 to 4 vote – a loss by one vote for mercury bay Community Board. This really translates to a loss for the local residents who put in their submissions and worked with their Community Board.  Local voices lost and in some ways the presentation by the District Manager included information that had not been made available before the Council meeting in Thames. 

The Mayor originally supported both the Community Board’s position and the views expressed in local submissions. However, a staff report appears to have changed the direction of the debate. District  Manager Dean Allen, advised the meeting  that if the reclassification proceeds, decision-making authority would move from the Department of Conservation (DOC) to Thames-Coromandel District Council (TCDC). He emphasized that reclassification does not automatically mean there will be changes to the use of the land.

Dean referred Councillors to recommendations by the Mercury Bay Community Board two electoral terms earlier (20/21) a further recommendation for reclassification made on 25 September 2025, just days before the 2025  local elections. Dean also made reference that he felt the current Community Board had not had sufficient time to fully understand the background, assess alternative parcels of land, or engage with stakeholders. 

“The current board has not yet reviewed all potential land parcels or met with all stakeholders.” Dean included this to  contextualized the reasoning behind why the current Community Board was not in favour of the classification 6 votes to one. 

The principle of Community Boards making recommendations on local matters was  addressed by the Mayor and he asked the meeting to consider the strong view point by the current Mercury Bay Community Board members. 

Several speakers minimized the significance of the debate by describing it as “only a reclassification” that “doesn’t determine use”. Opponents to the re-classification had  had argued that changing the classification could enable future developments that many local residents do not support. They contended that if the proposal is abandoned, decision-making remains with DOC.

Over recent years, the site has been considered for pensioner housing, an arts trust facility and, more recently, as a potential location for a community marae. Supporters and opponents  of retaining the current classification argued this demonstrated the ongoing lack of suitable land available for community wellbeing initiatives. However, the submission from local residents who were unanimous in their opposition to re-classifying the reserve had described how the current reserve was used by the local residents for a lot of leisure activities and social interaction. It had recently been planted with fruit trees with  the involvement of local residents. 

The issue was publicly notified and submissions were received. However, some questioned whether the current Community Board had been given the same information as its predecessor. Despite that, staff have continued to recommend reclassification, which would transfer authority from DOC to the Council.

During questioning, Councillor Rasmussen asked whether the Sheriff Block, a large parcel of land near the runway, had been considered. Staff confirmed there had been no recent work examining that option.

Questions were also raised about the reported loss of informal recreation space. Dean Allen said some submitters believed a marae development would reduce public access, although some current activities, including off-leash dog use, are not formally permitted.

Community Board Chair Richard Shelford-Woodcock stressed that the decision concerns classification, not future activities. “I want to clearly convey the position of the Board – this decision about classification about Moewai park is not a decision about what activity it can be used for”. Nevertheless, he continued,  the Community  Board’s position is clear -six of the seven members support retaining the current classification, with only John Grant favouring reclassification.

Road next to green field
road next to green field

“Ten submissions, plus one submission supported by 24 signatories, opposed the proposal.” Richard concluded that the Community  Board subsequently resolved that Moewai Park should retain its current classification.

Councillors sought clarification about Council’s level of control if a marae or arts facility were proposed. Staff explained that reclassification would give Council greater control over future decisions, although any specific proposal would still require further approval.

Concerns were also raised about the evidence used to assess reserve usage. Staff acknowledged there has been no formal monitoring programme and that assessments were largely observational. The report itself notes that no systematic information has been collected about recreational activities on the reserve.

Several councillors said they had expected a relatively straightforward decision but were hearing new information during deliberations. Councillor John Freer questioned what was different, what had changed since the very early recommendations and the current recommendation? He answered his question by saying, ‘the people’ that is really all that has changed; therefore  he would be voting for the re-classification.

Staff advised there was no significant risk in delaying the decision. The only consequence would be postponing a process that had already gone through public consultation.

Sadly, the public consultation which is about people, has not been heeded. The Mercury Bay  Community board is  very  involved in their locality and  well acquainted with the issues.   They were representing their local community. The Councillors,  not local have decided the outcome of the classification largely due to one Manager’s  presentation.  The mayor spoke an advised that local opinon and voice be heard. We are still not there.  Let’s wait to see if it is the staff or locally elected Councillors who decide the future usage of Moewai Park reserve. 


Gift this article