Skip to main content

Promotion of sea wall simplistic and parochial

 |  Maureen McGill  | 
The Informer’s promotion of a seawall for a few coastal properties is simplistic and parochial. It’s as if only Buffalo Beach has coastal hazards when every coastal community has them.

TCDC’s Shoreline consultants say 145 peninsula coastal locations require capital works for hazard “protection”.  Seawalls for just 7 of these local communities will cost $1.2 billion.  Now scale that nationwide around New Zealand’s 15,000 km coastline. (Netherlands has just 451 km, so a bogus comparison) That’s a fiscal black hole too huge for any government. Our small communities will miss out on government seawall funding.

Seawall costs will fall on all district ratepayers.  Sensible ratepayers who heeded climate science will have to subsidise a minority of beachfront owners who ignored three decades of warnings about rising sea levels and increased hazard risk, including from Council in LIM reports, building/resource consents and land titles.  We need personal responsibility, not ratepayer bailouts for wrong private property choices.

TCDC’s consultants propose a 6.4-metre-high rock barrier encircling Whitianga costing $342 million.  So, goodbye to sea views and beach/estuary amenities.  The community’s connection to the coast will be walled off, and Whitianga’s coastal visitor appeal – gone burger.

Even then, we’re not truly protected.  Seawalls will routinely fail when tsunamis and increasingly frequent extreme storms strike, leaving us clinging to the illusion of safety.

In many places, people will have to retreat.  Some may get capped buyouts if parties in Parliament can agree on the criteria, (but probably not for holiday homes).

Contrary to The Informer article, there are no quick or cheap fixes to the climate crisis.

Recent Letters to the Editor

Letters to the editor

Alice Thru The Looking Glass?

Inside out, upside down, and basically incomprehensible; comparable perhaps to going down the rabbit hole with Alice…………. A fair description of TCDC’s proposed Esplanade Project? Absolutely fascinating how 12million+ of our hard-earned ratepayer dollars has been  applied to a project that was a…
Letters to the editor


While on occasion offering sensible commentary on local governance issues, Dal Minogue thoroughly embarrassed himself (and The Informer) with his vicious remarks personally attacking long-time local environmental advocate John Veysey (The Informer April 9). Minogue’s nasty, juvenile, and defamat…
Letters to the editor


There’s got to be a way to effectively object to the consent request by DOC in last weeks issue on page 31. I feel like getting together an Objector’s Petition. This is about the relocation of the Mercury Bay Boating Clubhouse from its current site to being adjacent to the Dundas Street Boat Ram…
Letters to the editor


Just a few days ago, I received a notice informing me that the next day the council in its wisdom has decided to chip seal our road. For a council that cries poor in the justification for substantial rate rises, it seems to be a complete and utter waste of money. Our particular road is a cul de …
Letters to the editor


To all users of the Dundas Street boat ramp, remember that when the Marina was built, it was required to build a boat ramp and parking for the community free of any charge to use. When it is busy, there is no room to park all the vehicles and trailers on the existing site and you have been using…
Letters to the editor

Esplanade not our pet project or brainchild.

We are writing in response to Ady Cole-Ewen’s article, Esplanade – Tsunami Sirens, published 9 April 2024. The author writes “It is reported that the Esplanade’s “nice-to-have” upgrade is the brainchild and pet project of Councillors, Deli Connell and Rekha Giri Percival…” For the record this pr…
Letters to the editor

MORE POETRY FROM JOHN (received before dal minogue’s sent in his poetic response)

Who’s crying? Who’s given up on the fray and who’s been brought down and who’s making nonsense of the world today? Lies been raining down upon us. Life’s value has took a dive. But for those of you who see a dismal future, just remember you’re still alive. You’re still alive, you’re still al…
Letters to the editor

More disinformation

The guest editorial (Through the Portal) on EVs by Trevor Ammundsen is full of misinformation. EVs in New Zealand are not fossil fuel-powered. About 85% of our electricity is generated without any use of fossil fuels, and with several significant solar farms and further wind farms coming online,…
Letters to the editor

Kubota Fishing Competition

Well I hope now all of you who supported the MBGFC Kubota fishing competition are revelling in the millions of dollars, it supposedly brought to our once ‘sleepy little east coast fishing village’. We are now known on the world stage as the largest wild animal competition hunting field on the pla…
Letters to the editor


A letter to the editor in The Informer Issue 19 March, cited some information in a Newsroom article that was wrong, and which Newsroom has since corrected. The Informer letter to the editor was written by Meg Beston (Not TCDC’s Fault, 19 March issue) and cited Council debt figures published in a…