LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

This Week's Issue

Written by

The Informer

Published on

Questioning the use of “unused’ funds Further to the ‘Open Letter to the Minister’ in last week’s The Informer, I understand that the $90,000 casually uplifted by Council and used to fund a consultant to move the Esplanade Project forward earlier than stated in the LTP, was unused funding from a Wharekaho project that did…

Questioning the use of “unused’ funds

Further to the ‘Open Letter to the Minister’ in last week’s The Informer, I understand that the $90,000 casually uplifted by Council and used to fund a consultant to move the Esplanade Project forward earlier than stated in the LTP, was unused funding from a Wharekaho project that did not proceed?

Whether or not this is the case, the words “Unused funds” would perhaps be better termed as “Reallocated Funds”.  The question then is, ‘Who decided that these Reallocated Funds were better spent on a consultant for the Esplanade Development rather than fixing any one of the Health and Safety issues at Wharekaho, or elsewhere on the Peninsula?

Where are the Minutes of the Meeting on the TCDC website showing who voted for, or against reallocating the funds, and what was the science or process behind this decision?

There is already $12.75 million budgeted for the Esplanade project.  Is the $90,000 in addition to this amount or will it be subtracted from it?

Just how much more “Unused Funding” is being held by TCDC that could be “Reallocated” immediately to address Health and Safety issues?   

Wharekaho first asked for a safe footpath along the SH25 35 years ago. Population increase has young children, along with the very elderly, negotiating a narrow SH with ditches on both sides and trucks and trailers, and commercial and private vehicles, using the SH as a race track.  Pleas for Speed Cameras have been ignored.  There is no safe space for the school bus to pick up and/or drop children off. Flooding increasingly sees Simpsons Beach cut off from access to Whitianga.  No reticulated water, no sewage, and bore water tainted, at different times, with fecal matter, chemicals and minerals.

How amazing it would have been to have had just one of these important Health and Safety issues addressed by Council, rather than choosing to spend up large on a “Nice to Have” .

I can see that ’Esplanade Development Project’ has been in the Long-Term Plan for some time but never with any detail or budget until the last flurry of information on the website. This was done as a reaction to the public comment that people were frustrated and disappointed because they had not been consulted and had not received any information.

This project had been progressed with selected ‘invitation only’ interest group meetings – behind ‘closed doors’.  Surely it is time now to no longer work in direct opposition to, and ignoring our Prime Minister’s request to “Do the Basics Brilliantly”.

Ady Cole-Ewen, Wharekaho

Challenging Councils: Legal Delusions and Misinformation

The editor was far too polite in her reporting of the “Challenging Councils” meeting she recently attended with her description of “conspiratorial inference” (Informer 24 September)

I instantly regretted attending the group’s meeting in Thames.  I was shocked by how deeply they misunderstood the law and civic responsibility. Their pseudo-legal nonsense is rooted in misinformation, driven by conspiracy theories and a refusal to face reality.

The Challenging Councils group is an offshoot of the “Sovereign Citizen” movement in New Zealand which is a laughable exercise in delusion.   These self-appointed “experts” insist that they aren’t bound by the laws of the very society they live in, yet still enjoy its legal and civil rights protections.

The idea that Mayors and Council Chief Executives are personally liable for the lending a council undertakes or that signing a piece of paper magically exempts them from legal obligations is utterly absurd.

Worse, they’re pulling innocent people into their delusions, convincing them to take pointless actions that achieve nothing. Their absurd claims have been universally dismissed in court.

Thankfully the vast majority of New Zealanders roundly rejected their weirdo local body election platforms in 2022 and will do so again in 2025.

Denis Tegg

Retired Lawyer, Thames

Concerned about Editor’s opinion of Challenging Councils

From what you wrote, I wondered if we had attended the same event.(Whitianga- Challenging Councils at Bowling Club).

You mentioned “two alarming aspects”; firstly Mark’s attitude. My perception of him was very different to yours. I saw Mark as being a true blue, older kiwi Pākehā bloke from the provinces.

His saying that the South Island doesn’t have any Māori tribes or any Māori names, I knew that he didn’t seriously mean it because a man of his age, and financial acumen, would know about Ngāi Tahu, and Ngāi Tahu Holdings.  And yes, compared to the North Island, the South Island is Māori name sparse. I sensed that Mark had some vital information to present, so was willing to dismiss his flippant remark, as just that;  aremark that in his old school company probably wouldn’t make anybody flinch as it wasn’t racially charged, just a throw away comment that could easily have been about the Scottish heritage of Dunedin.

If you have been paying attention, you surely must be seeing how successive governments are using Māori in many ways, to divide the nation, creating angst, fear, torment and disharmony which further contributes to disempowering and marginalising Māori, which further drives the wedge between Pakeha and Māori. Meanwhile, these distractions keep most of us from paying close attention to what is really going on inside councils, parliament and overseas.

For Bess Kingi to feel frustrated about a reference to Māoridom is understandable but she had the opportunity to tick the “old bugger” off, and I’m sure that he would have taken it on the chin.

Maybe Bess’ frustration could be better directed at the Councils. As a ratepayer, Bess is like many of us who are struggling to see value for the increased rates, being ear tagged for exorbitant levels of proposed spending and then there is the borrowing as well, which is indicated in the Long-Term Plan (LTP).

There are rows and rows of eyewatering high numbers in the charts, extracted from the TCDC LTP which is available on its website.

Your second assertion, that Mark was being conspiratorial. Conspiratorial as far as I understand is suggestive of a secret plan made by two or more people to do something unlawful or harmful.

Continuing to increase rates can be very harmful. Without transparency of the actions of elected members and staff, how are we to know what is really going on, what our rates are  being used for and from whom is the council borrowing? The two or more people in the case of a conspiracy, which I noticed that some of the attendees had no idea about, are from the World Economic Forum, (WEF) and some from the United Nations (UN) and some of its agencies such as the World Health Organisation (WHO). It barely takes a few seconds to find such information on these organisations websites.

Watchdog Kathy Thompson,

Whitianga

Gift this article