Skip to main content

EVS VIRSUS ICE

 |  Peter Blank  | 
I find inaccuracies in the guest editorial (January 30, The Informer) by Denis Tegg on EVs.

Whitianga to Wellington is 655km by Google maps.  The EV has an average cost to fast charge of $10 per 100km or $65 plus $49 RUC (road user chargers) or total of $114 to Wellington.  ICE (internal combustion engine) vary from say 9 litres per 100km to 4.5 litres per 100km.Big car $218 or small car $114, cost of petrol.  Costs are the same for a small car versus a small EV. These figures for EV vehicles are for an average driver but as most EVs do have huge performance, if this is used, they will be more expensive to run than an ICE vehicle. Journey time for the EV is at least three hours longer to fast charge the battery. Using a fast charger frequently will degrade the battery’s life.

Next, the battery life of EV’s is projected to last 8 years or 100,000kms (Tesla figures off the internet).  Over time they degrade until they are no longer usable.  Then there is the problem of disposal. There is currently no viable way of disposing of them in NZ. Denis’ figures are inaccurate.

Car dealers will not trade in EVs because the best years have been had from them after a few years.

ICE vehicles on the other hand go for many years and are totally recyclable.

I drive only classic cars 22-48 years old. For the rest of their life, which can be considerable, the only cost is petrol as I am not buying either a new ICE or EV which both contribute hugely to the environmental damage to the planet when being produced

Classic cars are getting more popular. The cost of restoring them environmentally, is a fraction of a new EV and ICE car.

The costs calculated as above for the large vehicle is the same as fuel used in my classic car using 95 octane petrol.

Watch online when an EV burns so intensely, is totally consumed, and pollutes the atmosphere.

We are unique in NZ  in the distances we travel and our geography.  In the USA, Ford have, after a very short time, virtually stopped making the F150 EV small truck which in ICE form is the most popular vehicle of its type in the USA. This is because they are so impracticable to use, because of distances travelled and load carrying capacity.

Also, the introduction of road user charges for EV vehicles is coming but long overdue, as they are always heavier than ICE vehicles which pay their part in the cost of petrol.  Our roads are in bad shape. We don’t want heavier EV’s wearing them out and not contributing to the costs.

All my costs of ICE and classic cars are factual and can be proved.  On the other hand, no one with an electric vehicle will admit to the huge long-term costs of EV’s.

Overseas, where will all the fleet of millions of EVs be charged? Look at the UK where most of the vehicles are never garaged.  Some manufacturers of EVs recommend a special shed is built 100 meters from the house because of the risk of catastrophic EV fires burning so intensely.

ICE vehicles do not use materials that are inhumanly mined as in EVs and so the EV is extremely environmentally unfriendly to the planet.

In large parts of the world an EV is not an option because the batteries on EV’s shut down in the cold. This can happen in parts on New Zealand.

There are other options which Denis didn’t mention and that is hybrid or diesel vehicles, which is another consideration which will equate with classic cars but that is another story.

Governments are pushing for EVs as an easy way to save the planet, but it is far more complex than they are telling you.


Recent Letters to the Editor

Letters to the editor

An opportunity too good to miss

Recent articles and letters about the Lost Spring and an entrance sign to Whitianga bring up interesting ideas.  One of the things that make NZ unique on an international scene is its geological youth and consequent volcanic and geothermal activity.  Auckland sits on an active volcanic field with…
Letters to the editor

Pigs and poison

Kuaotunu resident, Tim, wants some pigs taken away. Pigs have been here since before the European settlers arrived and for centuries have provided a much-needed source of food. Demand was always bigger than the supply and pig numbers never got out of hand. This was before DoC arrived and began …
Letters to the editor

World Heritage Status for Mercury Bay. Public meeting date set

Thank you to all who contacted me so positively over my World Heritage Site  article in last week’s (9 July) The Informer. An incredible and very rewarding response. Including those who live outside of our area very much in support of extending the proposed boundaries. I can now confirm that we…
Letters to the editor

Re Welcome Signage to Mercury Bay

I so believe and endorse efforts to set up a more welcoming sign/s for folk coming to Mercury Bay and the Coromandel Peninsula. Many towns both within New Zealand and internationally have such signs with an icon which portrays the uniqueness of the area. Mercury Bay has ,I believe a plethora of …
Letters to the editor

Last week’s cartoon

Interesting cartoon in last week’s issue of the Huntly Power Station. It seems somewhat puzzling to this ancient relic when we have a perpetual source of power on the Power Stations doorstep in the Waikato River with today’s technology it is not put to good use. It is bewildering that unlike othe…
Letters to the editor

Integrity of Council

(Ref: Council disregards advice from Ombudsman – The Coromandel Informer, Issue 1113, 9 July,2024). Good on Cr Morrissey for standing up for the integrity of Council process against the performative nonsense of American refugees and pompous Mahakirau and Moehau poets.
Letters to the editor

Response from Council re segment of shoreline on Buffalo Beach

Regarding Oscar Hill’s letter to the editor in the 9 July issue of The Informer, about ongoing work on an eroded section of Buffalo Beach shoreline: Firstly, our Council would like to make it clear that reinstating a section of the shoreline following erosion last year is something our wider orga…
Letters to the editor

have you FORGOTTEN JAMIE?

Well, Jamie Boyle, Coastal Scientist, we are now into our eighteenth month since Cyclone Gabrielle took a bite out of our waterfront. Ten months after that event, you stated that you were still preparing the paperwork for resource consent to start the repairs. I concede it is a complicated proces…
Letters to the editor

Herald writer has wise message

I was impressed by Bruce Coterill’s article in the Business Section of the New Zealand Herald on Saturday, 22 June in which he detailed some of the negative reports coming out of the media. These include: • The stats are giving us bad news on a weekly basis • Protest rallies are regularly held …
Letters to the editor

I hit a pig!

I was returning from Whitianga at about 8.30am. I came around a corner, saw a glimpse of something big and black out of the corner of my eye and then, BANG! It was a large wild pig and it put my vehicle, which was not speeding, on two wheels and required a good deal of steering action. I was fo…