Skip to main content

EVs – time to ditch fearmongering!

 |  Paul Sommerville  | 
The endless torrent of misinformation about electric vehicles is exhausting! It’s riddled with hypocrisy and culture war knee-jerk undertones of “let’s attack ‘better’ because it’s not perfect, and let’s ignore ‘much worse’.

EV batteries use lithium, but its impact is dwarfed by the ongoing environmentally disastrous oil spills like Deepwater Horizon and Exxon Valdez which wrecked 4,000 miles of coastline. Don’t see any faux outrage for that.

Coal-powered electricity for EVs is utter nonsense. Coal imports are down while new EV car sales have risen to 20%!

Mr Barnes decries diesel-powered coal shipping but ignores shipping of five times that volume imported petroleum products, plus the oil spill risk to our coasts!

Modern EV batteries last over 300,000km, not your ludicrous claim of six years. After that, they have another life of 20 years as home energy storage to ease peak electricity demand. Finally, 95% of materials, including lithium are recycled.

EVs are 20 times less likely to catch fire than highly flammable petrol-powered cars.

Mr Sanders, your concerns about cobalt are misplaced. Most EV batteries use cobalt-free lithium iron phosphate (LFP). New sodium-ion batteries are also lithium and cobalt-free. Where’s your faux outrage that cobalt is used in refining petrol?

And conveniently silent are EV critics on NZ’s 300+ premature deaths and thousands of hospitalisations yearly from petrol/diesel pollution costing $15.7 billion per year, and $7 billion spent annually on imported fuel, all of which EVs avoid. EVs are demonstrably better for our economy, environment and our health. It’s time to ditch fearmongering and embrace a cleaner future.

Recent Letters to the Editor

Letters to the editor

Breakdown of $5 mill spend on Cathedral Cove track

It was great to read in Scott Simpson’s column last week that the new government has allocated $5 million from the tourist levy for DOC to get the Cathedral Cove track open again by this summer. This is surely good news for local businesses that depend on tourist traffic as well as the rest of u…
Letters to the editor

Where is Stan on Trump?

I see following a few missteps and an admittedly, terrible debate performance, Stan Stewart is calling for Joe Biden to step aside as Democrat candidate in the upcoming US election (9 July issue). But Stan, why haven’t you written a column about how unfit Donald Trump is to hold office as US pre…
Letters to the editor

Your recipes don’t work

The recent opinion article, ‘Fun recipes for better coalition leadership” (July 16, p.12) would indicate the writer’s culinary expertise comes from the Bear Grylls school of cooking; not pleasant eating. He also states, “I can’t see the logic”, a common socialist failing, but do not worry sir th…
Letters to the editor

Disappointing response on transparency

Highly disappointing, the article ‘TCDC slams door on Open Government Reform’ (The Coromandel Informer 9 July, p.2) has not triggered any meaningful reaction from readers other than Mr Minogue’s ludicrous comments (Letter to the Editor, 17 July). Unfortunately, pushing for more transparency and …
Letters to the editor

My stand on voting for Status Quo on Workshops

It’s essential to understand that I will vote as a Councillor in a way that I believe represents the interest of ratepayers for the District. This may not be my personal view but the view that I believe would be how the majority of ratepayers would want me to vote on an issue. So why did I in th…
Letters to the editor

Some cheer for this day

I read the “I am Meth” poem in The Informer of 9 July, first published 14 years ago, but still very timely. The poem is so well written even though it has been abbreviated a little. In my view, the suppliers of meth don’t receive nearly enough punishment for the harm it inflicts when consumed. …
Letters to the editor

Concern about race based seats

The drive to have seats on councils and in parliament for only Māori raises questions about our democracy and the thinking behind apartheid. Firstly, the problem that having race define the source of the MPs and the councillors means  should we not have seats for Chinese, Filipinos, Europeans an…
Letters to the editor

Social Responsibility – Social Licence

Both the Department of Conservation and their Contractors should be working with both. Both DoC and their contractors have a social responsibility not only to the Environment and the Community that they pick and choose, but to the wider community as a whole. Under consultation and permissions, D…
Letters to the editor

Policy plan needs change now – not later!

The NZ Coastal Protection Plan is ‘out of sync’ with countries in the western world in their policy that does not favour the use of rock walls, groins, or flood gates. The regional authorities come up with the strategy of ‘managed retreat’ to mitigate against coastal erosion – this strategy is u…
Letters to the editor

An opportunity too good to miss

Recent articles and letters about the Lost Spring and an entrance sign to Whitianga bring up interesting ideas.  One of the things that make NZ unique on an international scene is its geological youth and consequent volcanic and geothermal activity.  Auckland sits on an active volcanic field with…