Skip to main content



 |  Gerry Church  | 
RE: Fiona Gates’ reply to my letter

Regarding the term “Elite Māori”, Ms Gates says “The term Elite Māori is a derogatory term used to describe Māori leaders or those that speak up for Te Tiriti and Māori rights.”

While open to interpretation without asking the king directly, I can’t imagine that the king was applying that definition to the term when he said it.

It really doesn’t matter what Julian Batchelor said before Willie Jackson. Two wrongs never add up to one right. And actually, threats are a crime in New Zealand: Threatening to kill/do grievous bodily harm (Section 306 Crimes Act 1961).

Regarding the Boyd Massacre, killing and eating 70 human beings (take a moment and try to picture that horrific event in your mind’s eye) is justified in the name of upholding “prestige, authority, control, power, influence, status, spiritual power, charisma” because a young son of a local chief was “mistreated”? No context required. That punishment wasn’t proportional as the son of the chief wasn’t killed and eaten.

Back to the Treaty Principles Act. The Act website lists the principles as:

1. The New Zealand Government has the right to govern New Zealand.

2. The New Zealand Government will protect all New Zealanders’ authority over their land and other property.

3. All New Zealanders are equal under the law, with the same rights and duties.

What’s there to be afraid of? It doesn’t look like anyone would be getting any more or any less than anyone else since it would be clearly stated in law that everyone is treated the same.

One final note: A key component of a democracy is that everyone gets to have a say, most recently demonstrated at the last general election.

There are a whole lot of New Zealanders, myself included, who want a say on the Treaty Principles Act. Whether it’s voted up or down, at least we all have our say and we all must accept the result.

That’s democracy in action and is never too much to expect when one is living in a democracy.

Recent Letters to the Editor

Letters to the editor

We are all equal

Buddy Mikaere’s letter (6 February) is racist and promotes the specialisation of the maori race as a result of the formation of Maori wards. To address some of his extensive comments: The Treaty says we are all equal citizens under the law so why am I denied, because of my ancestors, the right to…
Letters to the editor

Elite Pakeha

Re: Response to Mr Church’s response to my response to his letter to the editor.
Letters to the editor

Nationhood – The Magic of Democracy

Democracy often clambered for but never fully realised and never always applied into a society that claimed to be democratic when choice was denied.  Slaves have no word.
Letters to the editor

TIC – Tongue In Cheek ailment

Dear Trevor I sincerely hope you are convalescing sufficiently from your recent and most difficult operation, when you had your tongue removed from your cheek. You obviously severely suffered mentally as you went thru the portal, as your column is actually making sense, which is most unlike your…
Letters to the editor

Don’t gloss over ICE vehicles

While it’s great Peter Blank enjoys his classic car, his recent letter about electric vehicles (EVs) contains many inaccuracies.
Letters to the editor


I wish to share ‘before’ and ‘after’ photos of an arborists work on our property. It’s difficult to get the real result through the eye of a cellphone.
Letters to the editor

Tairua – removing seedling mangroves from Pepe Stream

My wife recently posted a suggestion to remove seedling mangroves within the Pepe stream on Tairua chitchat. We believed this to be an open forum with reasonable debate and opinions offered. This appears not to be the case. Some abusive replies from a fanatical minority have convinced my wife to …
Letters to the editor

Fear need not rule

In 2012 Brigitte Meier took charge of Department of Conservation (DOC) activities on the Coromandel.
Letters to the editor


RE: Fiona Gates’ reply to my letter
Letters to the editor


The Informer’s Through the Portal opinion piece – ‘Local Authorities to act with Integrity’ took a critical stance towards the process TCDC used to establish Māori Wards in our region and has been triggering a flurry of diverse responses. The Mayor got in first with his weekly newsletter accusin…