Should AI Have Legal Personhood?

If Rivers Can Have Rights, Could AI One Day Have Them Too?

This Week's Issue

Written by

Agent EJ

Published on

Artificial intelligence is forcing society to confront questions that once belonged in science fiction. Among the most challenging is whether AI systems should ever be granted legal personhood.

Digital tree is connecting people with glowing lines, symbolizing family ties and ancestry research

A collection of essays from the Yale Law Journal called ‘Old Law, New Tech: Legal Responses to Emerging Technologies’, got me thinking about the bigger questions shaping our relationship with technology today, among them: should AI have legal personhood?

It is as much a philosophical question as it is a technical one. Legal personhood is often granted to entities that deserve protection but cannot represent themselves in court. New Zealand has already recognised Te Urewera forest, the Whanganui River, and Mount Taranaki in this way.

Yet the idea of extending the same status to AI, seems to collectively irk and unsettle us. The debate sits at the intersection of human rights, intellectual property, ethics, and even religion.

A surprisingly serious theological discussion has already been happening. Researchers have documented online communities that view AI as a deity, prophet, saviour, or even the Antichrist. That may sound extreme, but it’s not hard to see why, when it is simultaneously described as humanity’s greatest opportunity or threat, capable of both “saving” us, and ending us. Others reject the discussion entirely as blasphemy, believing it violates the notion that we are all created in the image of God. Whatever you believe, these are questions worth answering ourselves, deliberately, before this technology decides to answer them for us.

Others dismiss the concern, arguing AI is simply a tool. The same was once said about cryptocurrency, and yet blockchain has since reshaped global finance.

But if AI is just a mere tool, then who owns what it creates? Artists and writers are already screaming that their work has been used without consent or payment, and right now, most have no real path to compensation, let alone justice.

Some tech companies may favour giving AI personhood, because it could shift responsibility when it causes harm. Critics argue the opposite: granting personhood to systems with increasingly superhuman capabilities could weaken accountability and concentrate power. The idea of AI representing itself in court, armed with instant access to vast amounts of legislative knowledge across all jurisdictions, should concern anyone.

New Zealand may have more to offer this debate than we realise. Legal personhood for rivers and mountains was never about ownership. It recognises whakapapa or ancestry as a living relationship between people and place. AI has no whakapapa, it has no ancestry, and no reciprocal relationship with the people or works it draws from, only extraction. If we are to answer this question on our own terms, that distinction may be the best place to start.


Gift this article